Otterbein's Bakery | Buy Cookies Online | Cookie Delivery | Shop

Online Store

Discover products you can only find online at


First-Time Orderer

“Dear Otterbeins, My cousin recently brought some of your cookies to our house as a high school graduation ‘additional present’ – and all my grown children acted as if they had never eaten a cookie before!! As a recent addict to your cookies, I am hoping to send these gluttonous children each a shipment this Valentine’s Day. I am wondering if you have any coupons for free shipping code available – that would certainly help!

Thanks, and I am happy to be a new member of your newsletter!”

– Kay

Corporate Gifting

Otterbein’s Bakery can provide cookie gifts to businesses to recognize their customers, clients and employees.

More Information >>

Request A Login >>


Copyright 2016. All Rights Reserved.